adickaboutspoons:
It’s giving Romeo and Juliet and it is making me DERANGED
AS PROMISED here’s the mini essay that’s been brewing in my brain since I saw this post (it all came together with these last two episodes):
Most people (understandably, given how the play is taught in high school) are in two camps when it comes to Romeo and Juliet: 1.) it’s one of the greatest love stories of all time, or 2.) it’s a story about how two idiot teenagers kill themselves over hormones
Both of these readings are short-sighted.
People often forget that Romeo and Juliet doesn’t end with a double suicide, it ends when all of the surviving characters come back on stage and the prince is like “well, I guess we have to face the fact that our toxic community is fucking killing our kids.”
It doesn’t matter if Romeo and Juliet found true love, what matters is that their community is adamant that blind hatred is more important than their children’s happiness. And because of this, when Romeo and Juliet want to be together, there’s a deep panic in both of them. It causes them to rush–the whole play starts to rush, really, once Romeo kills Tybalt. From that moment on, it’s this mad dash to figure out how to be together, because clearly they just don’t have time. They can’t possibly have time when their families are saying “we’d rather see you dead than love who you want.” Their relationship would be drastically different if they felt like they had the safety to slow down and develop things normally.
Anyone else hear the word “whim” flitting about?
Ed and Stede live in a world that would rather see them dead than be the men they want to be, particularly the men they want to be with each other. And I’m not just talking about romantic-gay here, I mean pirating, existing on the fringes, being soft, “a lot of what we’re taught about being a man is wrong.” The British at their backs saying “renounce your life and come to war, don’t die for love, die for hate.”
So both Ed and Stede get the instinct to rush (albeit in different ways). We get where we are in the story because neither of these men feel like they have time to stop and think. I don’t believe either of them are inherently prone to whims. They were both taught in different ways that they always have to be running to stay ahead of the monsters society has set on them.
But the big difference that sets Ed and Stede apart from Romeo and Juliet is that they’re not kids. This may be their first real romance and makes them feel like teenagers (and in many ways both have a lot of growing up to do) but they’re not actual, literal teenagers. They’re grown men who have learned (even if flawed) ways to take care of themselves. It’s too late for their parents to learn their mistakes and try to start fixing what they broke. Now Ed and Stede, and the community they’re building, need to fix it themselves.
Ed briefly slipped back into feeding the hatred the world wants him to feel, and it was destructive for his whole community. But he came back, and so did Stede. They didn’t die. Not just because of true love, but because they’re the adults in the story that need to find a way to rebuild what the world keeps trying to force them to break.
[exit]
(did this live up to the promise, @adickaboutspoons?)